Running for the shower, my hands wrapped in singed pajamas, gripping a toaster oven belching flames, I began to wonder: where did it all go wrong?

As you may have deduced, Maria and I are trying to move to a new apartment about a hundred yards from our old apartment. It was Sunday night. In less than a week it would have been the two-year anniversary of the toaster’s purchase, and it was the first time we tried to cook anything with the toaster in the new place. Maria was trying to heat up some leftover restaurant tortilla chips (restaurant tortilla chips are very good, but only hot) and asked me how I usually heated them. I foolishly told her to toast them on medium.

Maria: ACK! Brendan, our chips have burst into flames!
Toaster Oven: REVENGE

I proceeded to treat the situation with a carefully thought-out policy of not opening the toaster door, and then, after a few seconds, opening the toaster door. The flames streamed upward like a reverse baby waterfall. Maria began to express concern over the possibility of activating our fire alarms.

Toaster Oven: THROW ME OUT OF THE WINDOW NOW, HU-MANS
Brendan: No! We’re never allowed to open the windows in here, because one of us is mildly afraid of bugs.
Maria throws open the windows.
Brendan: It’s not me.
Toaster Oven: HA HA PAN-SY

But off the stage, things weren’t going so well. Toaster Oven was slowly descending into a nightmare of booze and pills.

Brendan: I guess I knew things were falling apart when, after one session, I had to wrap my hands in old pajamas, grab Toaster Oven and throw him into the shower.
Toaster Oven: MY HABITS WERE OUT OF CON-TROL
Maria: That night was kind of what brought me to my senses. If this was the condition our lead guitarist was in, how much longer could the band last?

As it turned out, not long at all. Maria and Brendan intervened with water, followed by a heavy dose of baking soda. The band’s creative spark was extinguished. Also, the fire.

Toaster Oven: YOU BAS-TARDS ARE THROWING ME IN THE DUMPSTER QUESTION MARK EXCLAMATION POINT
Brendan: This for your own good, Toaster Oven.
Maria: It’s actually not.

It took nearly two days, but Toaster Oven and the Hu-mans would eventually resurface–without Toaster Oven itself. Instead, Maria and Brendan plan to audition new toasters based on a grueling selection process that involves being both cheap and at Target.

Brendan: Aww, this one’s adorable!
Toaster Oven: ARF ARF, AND SIMILAR SOUNDS
Maria: I don’t know. Do you think you’re ready for the responsibility of a toaster oven?
Brendan: I’ll take it for a walk every day! I’ll feed and water it, and I promise I won’t get tired of it, I won’t! Plus it’s on sale.
Maria: Well… As long as you understand that–
Brendan: Hooray!
Toaster Oven: SINISTER LAUGH-TER